Lakeshore Preserve resale homes

Overview

Lakeshore Preserve is a single-builder Toll Brothers neighborhood in Horizon West, laid out along Lakeshore Pointe Drive and Shorebird Lane on the south shore of Panther Lake. It sits in Horizon West’s Village F, in unincorporated Orange County, and homes carry Winter Garden addresses. In a 2022 release, Toll referred to its “Lakeshore community” on Lakeshore Pointe Drive, which then housed a temporary sales center for a nearby Toll project. Builder sales have since wrapped up: on October 21, 2026, Lakeshore Preserve did not appear anywhere on Toll Brothers’ list of Florida communities. This guide lists it as sold out, and anyone buying here today is buying a resale.^{1,13,14,17,18}

Homes and builders

Toll Brothers built all of the homes. Orange County records show about 370 homes, roughly 286 single-family houses and 84 townhomes, on plats Toll recorded between 2015 and 2020. Most were built from 2017 to 2020, and the last was finished in 2023. No builder collections are for sale now, so there is no current price table. Resale listings mention single-family plans including the Sanibel, the Madeira and the Estates Collection Maranello, and townhome plans such as the Cicero. In 2024 the Orange Observer described the Santa Bella as the largest model offered in the community.^{1,2,4,7,8,12,14}

Recent activity gives a sense of value. In 2026, a townhome sold for $650,000 in March and a three-bedroom house sold for $690,000 in August. The Orange Observer reported a five-bedroom, 3,917-square-foot home selling for $1,020,000 in March 2026 and a five-bedroom, 4,300-square-foot home selling for $1,545,000 in June 2026. Active listings in October 2026 included a four-bedroom Sanibel at $849,900 and a lakefront Estates Collection home at $2,075,000.^{2,4,5,6,10,11}

Amenities and lifestyle

According to listing descriptions, residents share a clubhouse, a zero-entry resort-style pool, a fitness center, playgrounds, sand volleyball courts, a dog park and a fire pit. There is also a kayak launch and a community dock on the lake. One listing says the dock has views of the Magic Kingdom fireworks, which reflects how close the neighborhood is to Walt Disney World.^2,4,8

Costs to know (HOA, CDD and taxes)

HOA dues in MLS listings range from about $293 per month (a 2023 sale) to $431 per month for a single-family home and $476 per month for townhomes in 2025–2026 listings. Some 2026 listings say dues include lawn care, internet and cable. Orange County parcel records list no CDD for the neighborhood, and 2026 listings report none. Taxes are based on Orange County’s assessment of each resale, so check the current tax bill and expect a reassessment after purchase.^{2,4,5,6,7,8,14}

Location and commute

The neighborhood sits in the southern part of Horizon West, near the Waterleigh area and Hickorynut Lake. No builder or developer drive times are published. Use a mapping app to check commutes to Disney, Interstate 4 and downtown Orlando. Orange County Public Schools’ 2026-27 attendance zones assign the neighborhood to Panther Lake Elementary, Water Spring Middle and Horizon High.^14,15,16